The Napoleon of Thought Crime ([info]darthbeckman) wrote,
@ 2008-08-16 07:56:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Entry tags:politics, war

Majoring in the minors
A friendly reminder for those who are still following the war: Georgia started it. Russia's response has been grossly disproportionate, sure, but don't kid yourself about poor innocent Georgia. What saddens me about US-Russian relations today is that they didn't have to be this way. There is nothing intrinsic in either the Russian or US character that destines us to always be enemies. Our current rivalry is the result of the foreseen and avoidable consequences of many bad decisions since the end of the Cold War. I'm convinced a lot of it is just pure anti-Russian (or anti-slav) animus. McCain's hatred of Russia is white hot and uncompromising. If you're convinced Russia will be our eternal enemy until the Second Coming, then McCain's your man.

Many people get hung up on the form of government while avoiding altogether questions of its essence. From whence does the government derive its civil authority? If the source of the government's authority is rationalistic principles based on the unrestricted will of man - whether it's one dictator or an elected legislator - then we are not truly free, regardless of whether that government has the form of democracy or not.

Solzhenitsyn had the right idea: it does no good to change the form of government if the essence remains unchanged.

We were recently entertained by a naïve fable of the happy arrival at the “end of history,” of the overflowing triumph of an all-democratic bliss; the ultimate global arrangement had supposedly been attained. But we all see and sense that something very different is coming, something new, and perhaps quite stern. No, tranquility does not promise to descend on our planet, and will not be granted us so easily.



(4 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]ancapi
2008-08-16 05:17 pm UTC (link)
"Georgia started it" just like Finland "started it" in 1939 and Czechoslovakia "started it" in 1938.

This "Osetian girl" bears family name "Kokoeva", which indicates she's related to Osetian separatist warlord Kokoev. They were clearly bringing up Kremlin-forged war propaganda.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]mrbogey
2008-08-16 05:59 pm UTC (link)
Yea...and the "genocide" so far is still only a few dozen dead Ossetians.

Russia loves to mention that they're passport holders and citizens of Russia...well of course they are. Moscow years ago began handing out citizenship and passports to try and destabilize the region.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]ancapi
2008-08-17 10:52 am UTC (link)
"A few dozen Ossetians", most of whom were armed Moscow's trained militias, who commenced slaughtering ethnic Georgians in their villages.

Ossetia remains ethnically cleansed now - no Georgian inhabitants are allowed to return to their houses.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]solaecclesia
2008-08-16 09:39 pm UTC (link)
I accept Huntington's thesis in Clash of Civilizations: certain government and geopolitcal conflicts arise out of competing socio-cultural dynamics.

The Russians have just always been authoritarian, it's their type of democracy. I'm not excusing Stalinist atrocities but for the most part Russia just keeps to it's slavic zone of influence. I say leave them alone.

If Mexico let China in with missles and defense systems we'd drop bricks in a heart beat. So why can't Washington get the picture? Leave Russia alone, save your hand for when a real problem comes up.

This silly moralistic worldview where we have to be shining knights everywhere is a cataclysm waiting to happy.

On the flipside I can understand the anxiety of the people in Georgia over possible war-crimes or other very real issues. So we should definitely send diplomats to diffuse the situation. Russia doesn't want to stir the pot too much.

(Reply to this)


(4 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…